Skip to Content

Where to Sell Wheat Pennies (Where to Get the Best Price)

Are you looking for the best places to sell your wheat pennies?

You’ve come to the right place!

Wheat pennies, minted from 1909 to 1958, are a popular collector’s item, and their value can range widely depending on factors such as rarity and condition.

Wheat pennies, minted from 1909 to 1958, are a popular collector’s item, and their value can range widely depending on factors such as rarity and condition.

It’s crucial to find the right buyer who appreciates the true value of your collection so that you can make the most of this exciting opportunity.

In this article, we’ll explore various options where you can sell your wheat pennies, ensuring a smooth transaction and maximizing your profit.

From local coin sellers to online platforms, you’ll discover reliable and efficient ways to cash in on your valuable collection.

Stay tuned and get ready to learn the ins and outs of selling your precious wheat pennies!

Where to Sell Wheat Pennies featured image

Understanding Wheat Pennies

The Origin of Wheat Pennies

Wheat pennies were first minted in 1909 as a result of a collaborative effort between President Theodore Roosevelt and the artist Victor David Brenner.

They introduced the idea of having the image of Abraham Lincoln on the penny to commemorate his centennial.

This was the first time in US coinage history that a president’s portrait appeared on a coin.

Significance of Wheat Pennies

The Lincoln Wheat Penny holds a special place in the hearts of collectors and enthusiasts.

As a tribute to one of America’s most beloved leaders, these pennies served a symbolic purpose.

Beyond their historical significance, wheat pennies also come in various designs and rarities, making them highly sought-after by collectors.

How to Identify Wheat Pennies

To identify a wheat penny, you can look for certain key features, such as:

  • Obverse: The front side of a wheat penny will feature Abraham Lincoln’s image, which symbolizes his influence on American history.
  • Reverse: The back side of the penny is where you’ll find the distinctive wheat stalks flanking the words “ONE CENT”. This design is unique to the Lincoln Wheat Penny, making it easily recognizable.
  • Year: Wheat pennies were minted from 1909 to 1958, so any penny within that range is likely a wheat penny.
  • Mint mark: You’ll also want to pay close attention to the mint mark on your penny, as this can greatly affect its value. A small letter (D, S, or P) can be found under the date on the obverse side, indicating the minting location (Denver, San Francisco, or Philadelphia).

With a keen eye and a bit of background knowledge, you can easily identify and appreciate the unique qualities of wheat pennies.

Valuing Wheat Pennies

Valuing Wheat Pennies

Determining the Condition

When it comes to valuing wheat pennies, the first step is evaluating the condition of your coins.

A well-preserved penny from 1909 to 1958 can have a higher value than one in poor condition.

So, before selling your collection, take the time to examine your coins and identify any with exceptional preservation. This can make a world of difference in their final worth!

Coin Age and Rarity

Coin values are also impacted by their age and rarity.

For instance, rare pennies like the 1909 S VDB or 1944 Steel Wheat Penny are worth significantly more than common dates.

Keep an eye out for key dates and low mintage coins, as they can fetch a higher price when selling.

Moreover, older wheat pennies, particularly those from 1909, tend to be more valuable, so don’t forget to check the dates on your Lincoln cents!

Understanding Mintmarks

Finally, it’s crucial to understand mintmarks when valuing your wheat pennies.

Mintmarks refer to the letters indicating where a coin was minted.

The three main mintmarks are “D” for Denver, “S” for San Francisco, and “P” or no mark for Philadelphia.

Some rare pennies, such as the 1922 No D or 1943 cents, have unique mintmarks that can increase their value considerably.

Identifying the mintmarks on your coins will help you better determine their worth and ensure you get the highest possible value when selling your collection.

Selling Wheat Pennies

When it comes to selling your wheat pennies, you have various options to explore.

In this section, we’ll look at four popular avenues for selling wheat pennies: Local Coin Shops, Online Coin Dealers, Auctions, and Trading at Coin Shows.

Each option has its benefits and drawbacks, so consider them carefully to get the best deal for your collection.

Local Coin Shops

One of the most accessible options is taking your wheat pennies to a local coin shop.

These establishments are made up of professionals who can provide accurate evaluations of your items.

Selling your wheat pennies at a coin shop lets you interact directly with a knowledgeable professional, which means you can ask questions, negotiate, and get expert advice.

The downside is that the inventory at local coin shops might be limited, and they might not offer the highest price based on current market demand.

Online Coin Dealers

In today’s digital world, online coin dealers provide another platform for selling wheat pennies.

Websites like CoinStudy and Chronicle Collectibles offer competitive prices and cater to a wide customer base.

Online dealers can provide a quick, convenient way to sell your coins, but it’s essential to research their reputation and credibility.

Look for customer reviews and choose a reputable dealer to ensure a fair price and smooth transaction process.


Another option for selling wheat pennies is through auctions, either online or through physical auction houses.

If you have valuable or rare coins, selling them at an auction can fetch a good price, as collectors tend to gather at such events.

With auctions, you’ll be exposed to a broader market, making it more likely to attract higher bids.

However, selling through an auction can take more time than other methods, and you’ll need to pay a commission to the auction house.

Trading at Coin Shows

Coin shows are an excellent opportunity for both collectors and sellers to come together in one place.

Attending coin shows allows you to network with other enthusiasts, exchange ideas, and establish connections with potential buyers.

You can showcase your collection and possibly meet collectors willing to pay a fair price for your wheat pennies.

While coin shows can be exciting, it’s essential to be prepared—bring your coins in good condition and have a sense of their value based on market trends.

Where to Sell Wheat Pennies Key Considerations Before Selling

Key Considerations Before Selling

Before diving into the world of selling wheat pennies, there are some essential factors to consider.

This section will cover the importance of Professional Coin Grading and the value of Research and Knowledge.

Professional Coin Grading

One crucial aspect that determines the value of your Lincoln pennies is having them professionally graded.

professional coin grading service such as PCGS will help you determine the condition and, consequently, the worth of your coins.

Accurate grading by experts will make it easier for you to interact with potential buyers, who often rely on this information.

Your graded coins will boost your credibility and trustworthiness among coin collectors.

Research and Knowledge

Being knowledgeable about the Lincoln wheat pennies in your inventory goes a long way toward getting the best value for your coins.

Engage in thorough research to gain a proper understanding of their history, rarity, specific mintages, and key dates.

This information plays a significant role in commanding the right price from buyers, whether you’re selling through APMEX, auctions, or other platforms.

There are numerous resources available, both online and offline, to expand your knowledge in this area.

Remember that the more informed you are about your selection of wheat pennies, the better equipped you’ll be to make smart decisions regarding your personal finances.

Alternatives to Selling

Are you looking for alternatives to selling your wheat pennies?

You’ve come to the right place! Instead of selling, you have several exciting options to consider.

One option is to create rolls or bags of your wheat pennies.

Organize them by date or mint mark for a neat and fun way to store your coins.

This method not only keeps your pennies safe but also helps you appreciate the historical context of each coin.

Imagine holding onto a roll of San Francisco mint Lincoln wheat cents – it’s like taking a peek into the past!

Another fascinating alternative is to expand your collection.

Why limit your collection to wheat pennies when there are so many unique coins out there?

Look for other coins like Indian head pennies or uncirculated coins to add to your treasure.

You never know what valuable gems you might discover in your search, so always keep an eye out for coins with low mintage or unusual discoloration.

You can also exchange your wheat pennies for other coins that interest you.

Think of it as a bartering process where you swap pennies for other coins or even bullion.

It’s an exhilarating way to diversify your collection and continue your passion for numismatics.

Lastly, consider using your wheat pennies as pocket change, giving you the joy of spending these historical coins in your daily life.

Not many people can boast about buying their morning coffee with Lincoln wheat cents!

It’s a thrilling experience that adds an extra layer of excitement to your everyday transactions.

Where to Sell Wheat Pennies

Where to Sell Wheat Pennies: Final Thoughts

You now know some outstanding options for where to sell wheat pennies.

Broadening your opportunities to sell these cherished coins ensures that you make the most of your collection.

So, whether you choose a reputable online coin dealer, an auction house, your local coin shop, or even a collector’s market, you’re ready to make a well-informed decision.

Remember that understanding the value of your wheat pennies is crucial to getting top dollar for your collection.

Each venue will have its advantages and disadvantages, but sticking to reputable sources should always be a priority.

We hope through this information, your enthusiasm and excitement for selling wheat pennies will only grow, leading to fantastic sales and potentially even greater discoveries in your coin-collecting journey.

You’ve got this!

Go ahead and explore these options, and with a bit of patience, expertise, and luck, you’ll find the right buyer who appreciates your wheat pennies just as much as you do.

READ NEXT: Where to Sell Your Used Appliances and Make a Profit